Giving preferential treatment makes equal treatment unequal
![giving preferential treatment makes equal treatment unequal giving preferential treatment makes equal treatment unequal](https://theindianconstitution.com/wp-content/uploads/2021/02/Article-14-300x169.jpg)
And I quoted Bernice Johnson Reagon, a Freedom Singer from the Civil Rights era. The immorality of equal compensation for unequal services is an immorality which society always recognizes no matter what the attempts may be to secure inequality of compensation for equal services."Īs far as I know, that's the source, though it may be that Wright was citing some earlier source.Įlsewhere in my talk, I quoted noted community organizer (and Glenn Beck bête noir) Saul Alinsky, whose politics certainly leant to the left (though he wasn't a Communist or a Socialist). In any event, Bradford quotes: "There is no greater inequality than the equal treatment of unequals.
![giving preferential treatment makes equal treatment unequal giving preferential treatment makes equal treatment unequal](http://www.quotemaster.org/images/4d/4d5ab0cef204ff84e5cea12be3d3f022.jpg)
Reviewer Edward Bradford aligns Wright â formerly the US Commissioner of Labor â with socialists, saying that Wright's "collectivism" is simply a "new name for Socialism," though Bradford seems elsewhere to take an overly-expansive definition of socialism. The earliest citation I've been able to locate of who that "wise man" might be is in a book review from the 1906 New York Times, from a review of The Battles of Labor, a book on strikes and labor unrest in the Gilded Age and dawning progressive era, by Dr. It was a wise man who said that there is no greater inequality than the equal treatment of unequals. This is not to coddle Communists but to respect our professions of equal justice to all. This principle should be enforced whatever the tenets of the group - whether the old Locofocos or the Know-Nothings, the Ku Klux Klan or the Communists.
![giving preferential treatment makes equal treatment unequal giving preferential treatment makes equal treatment unequal](http://yoninetanyahu.com/wp-content/uploads/2021/02/MONROE-SCREW-AND-ORANGE-SILJ-SAREEA-WITH-AND-WHO.jpg)
The boast of our criminal procedure is that it protects an accused, so far as legal procedure can, from a bias operating against such a group to which he belongs. To take appropriate measures in order to avert injustice even towards a member of a despised group is to enforce justice. To recognize the existence of a group whose views are feared and despised by the community at large does not even remotely imply any support of that group.
Giving preferential treatment makes equal treatment unequal trial#
He was objecting to the trial of a Communist Party official convicted for refusing a subpoena to appear before HUAC, and wrote: In a 1950 Supreme Court dissent, Justice Felix Frankfurter said: "It is a wise man who said that there is no greater inequality than the equal treatment of unequals" Dennis v. You often see the correct version attributed to Thomas Jefferson, but rarely with any citation accurate enough to confirm. That's actually a misquotation (I was working from memory) of a line I've always loved, but have had a hard time tracking down. In the course of my talk at TAM, I mentioned at one point "There's nothing so unfair as equal treatment of unequal ideas." Various people tweeted and retweeted it, so the line was clearly a hit.